Changing perspectives / Perspectives dynamiques #2

Value of the Information & Strength of the Argument

The presentations offer valuable contributions to intermedial theory, grounding their arguments in philosophical traditions (e.g., Kant, Rancière) and contemporary media studies. The first speaker compellingly critiques classical ekphrasis models, borrowing from Mitchell and ancient rhetoric to propose a performative understanding. The second speaker integrates philosophical and cognitive science perspectives to problematize the notion of ‘presence’, illustrating with empirical examples. The argumentation is sophisticated and well-supported, though the poor transcription hampers full appreciation of nuance.

Scientific Rigor, Source Quality, Title Accuracy

The scientific rigor is high, with clear theoretical framings and references to canonical thinkers (e.g., Rancière, Ricoeur, Beuys). However, only one direct source link appears in the description (the conference website), limiting external verification. The title ‘Changing perspectives’ accurately reflects the shift from ekphrasis to presence and the broader scope of intermedial studies, albeit the third paper is underrepresented in the transcript. Overall, the content is solidly academic, but the lack of accessible sources and transcription quality modestly undermine its usability.

The title succinctly captures the colloquium's aim to shift perspectives across different presentations, aligning well with the diverse content.

7/10

The academic content is rigorous and theoretically grounded, but the automatic transcription is notably error-prone, making some passages difficult to follow.

Markers derived by PSI from the transcript: the creator did not define chapters.

• 00:00Introduction by the moderator and setup of the colloquium.
• 05:00First presentation begins: Janneke Schoene on ekphrasis and Beuys's performances.
• 30:00End of first talk and Q&A session with audience.
• 40:00Second presentation: Olivier Nannipieri and Hakim Hachour discuss 'From presence to hyperpresence?'.
• 1:20:00Transition to third presentation on intermedial subjectivities of skin and screen.

• Authentic Artifice Conference Website — Official conference website providing program and background for the 3rd International Colloquium of the International Society for Intermedial Studies.